The Comic Book Bin
Search
Comic Book Bin 
 
 Comics
 Comic Reviews
 Marvel Comics
 DC Comics (1203)
 Other Comics
 Back Issues
 Manga Reviews
 Comic News
 Spotlight
 Phil's Bubble
 European Comics
 Canuck
 Black Astronaut
 Comics 101
 Web Comics
 Comic Strips
 
 Action Figures
 
 Video Games
 
 Fan Films
 
 Movies
 
 Books
 
 Interviews
 
 About
 Classifieds
 Newsletter
 RSS

 
Comics : Comic Reviews : DC Comics
Last Updated: Jan 1, 2009 - 6:19:39 PM




Supergirl # 31
By Koppy McFad
Jul 5, 2008 - 12:54:48 AM

DC Comics
Writer(s): Kelly Puckett
Penciller(s): Drew Johnson
Inker(s): Ray Snyder
Cover Artist(s): Stephane Roux
$2.99 US, 32 pages
Email this article
 Printer friendly page

Add to Del.icio.us     Add To Reddit
Add To Digg     Add To Stumbleupon
Add To Technorati Favorites     Add To Ask


sgirl_1.jpg

Supergirl tries to save a young boy dying of cancer, even if it means using the blood of a superhuman but Superman steps in to keep her from making a horrible mistake even as the boy's condition worsens.

This book tackles the age-old comic-fan question, "if SUPERHERO X is so great, why can't he cure cancer? (or AIDS, or hemophilia, etc.)" Of course, such an approach risks turning the comic book into a "disease-of-the-week" TV movie which comes off as banal rather than dramatic.

The creative team thankfully, does not resort to miracle solutions to solve the problem. If anything, they make Supergirl's situation more controversial as both the parents and Superman raise objections to her "cure." The Supergirl character is still naive but her sincerity comes through the printed page. When she stands up to Superman and the parents and tries to explain herself, her arguments do seem a bit simplistic but they are also very moving, that the reader can't help but be convinced.

The art is also very understated. It does not resort to frequent extreme close-ups that highlight the tears running down the mother's face. Supergirl is still depicted as very attractive but doesn't come off as costumed jailbait as in so many previous issues. The flashback scenes of Supergirl being sent into space look very good as well.

The writer however does not give too much of the backstory to help new readers find out what is going on. Why does this one boy, of so many other terminally-ill patients, merit all this attention from Supergirl? There is also little information on this metahuman guy that Supergirl has dragged out to save the boy. Is this suppose to be Resurrection Man? If so, how come Superman doesn't recognise him. And if he isn't the old superhero, then why aren't we told more about him?

Just the same, this book is special. It tackles issues that are rarely tackled in mainstream comics-- and does the job well. The less mature readers out there may complain about the lack of action and the 'cliffhanger' ending. And maybe this kind of story can't really be done too often in comic books which rely so much on spectacle. But this issue is a nice change of pace.

 

Rating: 8/10

Related Articles:
Supergirl 35: New Krypton
Superman/Supergirl: Maelstrom # 1 (of 5)
Supergirl # 31
Supergirl # 22
Supergirl # 20
Supergirl # 19
Supergirl and the Legion of Superheroes # 31
Supergirl #15
Katie Norris - Confessions of a Teenage Supergirl
Confessions of a Teenage Supergirl



Comment Script Join the discussion:

Add a Comment

Comments


© Copyright 2002-2009, Coolstreak Cartoons Inc. - All rights Reserved. All other texts, images, characters and trademarks are copyright their respective owners. Use of material in this document(including reproduction, modification, distribution, electronic transmission or republication) without prior written permission is strictly prohibited.

Top of Page

Justice League of America #28
In this issue, the Justice League fights the Shadow Cabinet, the super heroes from the Milestone Imprint from DC Comics published in the early 1990s
Justice Society of America #20
It’s the end for Gog and his exile is about to begin
Green Arrow and Black Canary #15
Green Arrow has less than two seconds to save his wife, fellow heroine Black Canary from the blade of a mad man
Haunted Tank # 1 (of 5)
The Haunted Tank is updated to the war in Iraq with the ghost of a Confederate cavalry general partnered with an African-American tank commander.
Tangent: Superman's Reign # 10 (of 12)
The heroes from the mainstream DC universe team up with their "Tangent" counterparts to face the world-conquering 'Tangent Superman'.
Booster Gold # 15
Booster Gold encounters Elongated Man as he tries to track down a missing artifact that could change the path of history.
Action Comics # 872
The Creature Commandoes are revived as the people of Earth prepare to stand up to the newly-arrived Kryptonians.
Secret Six # 4
The Secret Six head of Las Vegas but their mysterious tormentor is waiting for them there.
The Spirit # 24
The Spirit goes to Cambodia to unravel the secret behind the murder of several Vietnam war vets.
DCU Holiday Special 2008
The heroes of the DC universe celebrate Christmas in different ways in a series of short stories about the holiday season.
Justice League of America # 27
The Milestone characters make their debut in the DC universe, facing off against the Justice League of America, no less.
Young Liars #10
Do Not Eat While Reading This Comic!
Final Crisis # 5 (of 7)
Darkseid takes control as the heroes make a last-ditch stand.
Ambush Bug: Year None # 5 (of 6)
Ambush Bug chases Dan DiDio across the multiverse.
Justice Society of America # 21
The horrible secret of Gog, revealed.