Comic Book Bin 
 
 Comics
 Comic Reviews
 Marvel Comics (689)
 DC Comics
 Other Comics
 Back Issues
 Manga Reviews
 Comic News
 Spotlight
 Phil's Bubble
 European Comics
 Canuck
 Comics 101
 Black Astronaut
 Web Comics
 
 Action Figures
 
 Fan Films
 
 Video Games
 
 Movies
 
 Books
 
 Interviews
 
 About
 Classifieds
 Newsletter
 RSS

Comics : Comic Reviews : Marvel Comics
Last Updated: Jul 5, 2008 - 8:12:15 PM



Civil War: The Initiative
By Al Kratina
Mar 28, 2007 - 8:10:02 AM

Email this article
 Printer friendly page

Add to Del.icio.us     Add To Reddit
Add To Digg     Add To Stumbleupon


civil-war-initiative01.jpg
Civil War: The Initiative #1

Marvel Comics

Writer: Brian Bendis (pages 1-12, 22-34), Warren Ellis (pages 13-21)

Penciller: Marc Silvestri

Inker: Joe Weems with Marco Galli & Rick Basaldua

Colorist: Frank D’Armata

Letterer: Troy Peteri

 

When did we start paying for commercials? Actually, Civil War: The Initiative is quite an inventive approach to advertising. Instead of wasting time with print ads, word of mouth, and viral marketing, why not charge people $6 for a comic book that’s nothing more than a collection of half-formed stories and two-page ad for upcoming Marvel titles? While you’re at it, he’s twenty bucks. Now tell me why I should drink Coke Zero.

 

As you may imagine, I’m less than impressed with Civil War: The Initiative. While I think the overall Civil War storyline is the most interesting comic event of the decade, that’s still now excuse for exploiting the idea by slipping readers product placement under the Civil War banner like a roofie in a Shirley Temple. This one shot starts out innocently enough, with a Brian Bendis penned story that deals with the aftermath of Alpha Flight’s destruction at the hands of The Collective. Bendis’ story has The Collective, or rather, Michael, the host The Collective inhabited, imprisoned in Canada while awaiting trial for the deaths of the team. This is the most fully realised story in the book, with crisp dialogue and Bendis’ trademark blend of naturalism and sharp humor. Still, as all the story essentially boils down to is an ad for Michael Avon Oeming’s Omega Flight miniseries, it deflates at the end, reducing itself to nothing more than an extended version of those Hulk Underoos ads with a less interesting product. Mark Silvestri’s pencils are razor sharp, and the layouts, especially a splash page of Sasquatch, are exciting and well thought out, but I’ve always found Silvestri’s work cold and distant, and there’s nothing in this issue to change my mind. Still, the talent and dynamism that has made Silvestri a fan favorite is obvious.  

 
What follows is a short Thunderbolts story, written by regular scribe Warren Ellis. Ellis is among the best writers in the industry, but he’s given 8 pages to deal with 8
civil-war-initiative04.jpg
characters, as the Thunderbolts team hunts down Hurricane. The fact that he still manages to make Penance and Bullseye shine in such a limited space is a testament to his abilities, but the story does nothing but give another example of what happens in the regular Thunderbolts series every month, with more cramping. This section contains my favorite artwork in the book, as Silvestri makes Bullseye look truly horrifying, almost feral, a barely contained vortex of insanity. And Penance looks like a broken S&M marionette, codpiece and all.

 
Next comes another Bendis story, in which Warbird argues with Spiderwoman for a few pages, then Tony Stark essentially turns to the reader and politely asks them to buy The Mighty Avengers. It’s a lot of dialogue that’s well written but goes nowhere other than providing the set up to The Mighty Avengers #1. I already bought that comic, so I feel like my time has been somewhat wasted. And on that down note, Civil War: The Initiative degenerates into a series of 2 or 4 page previews of Captain America, Iron Man, The Mighty Avengers, and The Avengers: The Initiative, filler in a book that already feels empty.

 

Rating: 5 on 10

 

Email the author.

 

 


Related Articles:
"What If?" Visits "Civil War"
Civil War: Confessions
Civil War: The Initiative
Civil War #7
Civil War: The Return #1
Civil War #5
Civil War #6
Civil War: Choosing Sides
Civil War's Thunder
Civil War: Choosing Sides #1



Comment Script Join the discussion:

Add a Comment

Comments


© Copyright 2002-2008, Coolstreak Cartoons Inc. - All rights Reserved. All other texts, images, characters and trademarks are copyright their respective owners. Use of material in this document(including reproduction, modification, distribution, electronic transmission or republication) without prior written permission is strictly prohibited.

Top of Page

Search

Astonishing X-Men #25
The first issue following the Whedon and Cassidy run, does it live up to impossible standards?
Secret Invasion Front Line #1 of 5
Secret Invasion Front Line tells the story of the Skrulls’ invasion of New York City and the world, from the perspective of regular humans
Avengers Invaders #1 0f 12
When heroes and villains from two eras meet, can any of them survive the encounter?
Avengers Initiative #14
Is there a Skrull in the house?
The Invincible Iron Man #2
Iron Man is still on the trail of the technology used by his armour and this time, he fights an AIM splinter group and their very own Modok who calls itself Modog
The Amazing Spider-Man #564
You'll laugh, you'll cry, you'll run screaming through screen doors.
Eternals #1
This new series continues where the last one by Neil Gaiman and John Romita Jr. left off last year
Runaways #30
The Runaways hop in their De Lorean and fly home
Ultimate Spider-Man #123
My momma always said life was like a bunch of symbiotes
Skaar Son of Hulk #1
And thus Skaar Son of Hulk was born
Hulk #4
Deja vu, key of green.
Ultimate Origins #1
All filler, no killer for much-hyped mini-series
Kick Ass #3
Millar and Romita Jr. continue to prove the namesake
Secret Invasion #3
This issue is not great and there are few developments that help carry the story within this series
The Amazing Spider-Man #562
Double the Spider-Mans = double the neuroses.