Comics / Comic Reviews / DC Comics

The Plain Janes

By Leroy Douresseaux
June 8, 2007 - 07:02

Thanks to for the image.
The Plain Janes by writer Cecil Castellucci and artist Jim Rugg is the first title from Minx, a DC Comics’ imprint focusing on slim graphic novels that fit in the fiction publishing category, YA or “Young Adult.”

The Plain Janes has as its lead character Jane Beckles, a lively teen girl, enjoying life in Metro City (a stand-in for New York City?), when tragedy strikes.  Now fearful of living in the city, Jane’s parents spirit her off to suburban safety in the form of the town of Kent Waters.  Jane, still somewhat in shock, leaves behind her hip city friends for the strangeness of Buzz Aldrin High.

Jane’s innate coolness and confidence attracts the attention of Buzz Aldrin’s pretty girl clique and their leader Cindy Sanchez, but Jane spies another group of girls who might form the perfect tribe for her – three other girls named “Jane.”  There is Jane, the actor/comedian, Jayne, the pretty, smart girl and scientist wannabe, and Polly Jane, the athlete.  Although the other Janes are at first reluctant, they eventually bond with Jane Beckles over pulling pranks.  They form an “art attack” group and call themselves P.L.A.I.N.People Loving Art in Neighborhoods.

The pranks (like putting wool caps on fire hydrants) are meant to introduce art to the stale suburbia of Kent Waters and to encourage creative expression.  Instead, their guerilla art stunts create anger and hostility among the adults, especially Jane’s mother, who is becoming more and more paranoid following the events that made the family move from Metro City.

The Lowdown:  Upon first glance, the teen characters in The Plain Janes might seem like stereotypes, and while each one is of a well-worn teen fiction type, there is, of course, a method to writer Cecil Castellucci’s madness.  Using such familiar characters allows the author a clear path to expressing ideas and themes.  That the Janes and the other Buzz Aldrin students seem familiar helps the writer engage readers with the characters while she can use the overall story to delve deeper into such issues as acceptance, friendship, first love, fear, and self-determination.

Of course, the Janes and the student body come across as naïve.  In spite of their personal fears and struggles, their optimism here is exceptionally refreshing in a world where even “family entertainment” is rife with innuendo and unimaginative cynicism.  Of the many things, this book says, one is “the children, with their creativity and curiosity, are our future, so let’s mortgage that future by teaching them fear, ignorance, and blind obedience and then, insisting that they learn that in place of hope and potential.”

Rugg superbly captures all the nuances in mood and atmosphere in Castellucci’s story.  From the naked fear of Jane’s mother and the bullying insistence of Officer Sanchez to “TheatreJane’s” pretentious flair and “SportyJane’s” tough, but smooth tomboyish persona, Rugg finds the unique accent within each of Castellucci’s seemingly typecast characters.  Rugg also nicely balances the light and dark elements of the setting and story.

For readers of:  Although geared towards female YA, anyone who likes “Freaks and Geeks” may very well like this.  The Plain Janes is also a young cousin of Daniel Clowes’ essential graphic novel, Ghost World, so some fans of alt-comix could have love for this.  Although occasionally rough around the edges, this is a treat that left me wanting more.




Last Updated: August 31, 2023 - 08:12

    RSS       Mobile       Contact        Advertising       Terms of Service    ComicBookBin

© Copyright 2002-2023, Toon Doctor Inc. - All rights Reserved. All other texts, images, characters and trademarks are copyright their respective owners. Use of material in this document (including reproduction, modification, distribution, electronic transmission or republication) without prior written permission is strictly prohibited. Toon Doctor ® is registered trademarks of Toon Doctor Inc. Privacy Policy