Comic Book Bin 
 
 Comics
 Comic Reviews
 Marvel Comics
 DC Comics (1123)
 Other Comics
 Back Issues
 Manga Reviews
 Comic News
 Spotlight
 Phil's Bubble
 European Comics
 Canuck
 Comics 101
 Black Astronaut
 Web Comics
 
 Action Figures
 
 Fan Films
 
 Video Games
 
 Movies
 
 Books
 
 Interviews
 
 About
 Classifieds
 Newsletter
 RSS

Comics : Comic Reviews : DC Comics
Last Updated: Jun 14, 2008 - 9:44:13 AM


Justice League of America # 17
By Koppy McFad
Jan 19, 2008 - 1:15:29 AM

Email this article
 Printer friendly page

Add to Del.icio.us     Add To Reddit
Add To Digg     Add To Stumbleupon


jla_2.jpg

DC COMICS
WRITERS: Dwayne McDuffie, Alan Burnett
ARTISTS: Ed Benes, Jon Boy Meyer, Sandra Hope
COVER: Ethan Van Sciver

The Suicide Squad is hunting down the world's supervillains... and the supervillains are running to the Justice League.

The main story in this issue ties in with events in the whole SALVATION RUN and SUICIDE SQUAD miniseries. But you don't need a deep understanding of these books to tell what is happening here. The scenes of various badguys-- both big names and small fry-- trapped and frightened, are surprisingly effective. It is enough to make you feel sympathy for a Neo-Nazi or a crazed killer. The ending also sets up a clever cliffhanger-- one that is not dependent on the hero being put in peril.

Ironically, among the main weaknesses in the main story is the failure to flesh out some of the villains. A choice few get the spotlight but many of the bad guys are reduced to standing in the background. The art merely compounds this problem. There is an overuse of dark shadows and muscular characters posing, to the point that it becomes difficult to tell what is happening in many of the panels. Is that big, white, muscle-man suppose to be the Ace of the Royal Flush Gang? Isn't he a robot? And is that suppose to be the Tattooed Man in the background? Is it the original (a white guy) or the new one (a black guy)? The art is so muddled, it becomes hard to tell black from white. In the Silver Age, they would be nice enough to include some panels, listing all the characters. Or at least the villains would address each other by name so we would know who was speaking to who. This new modern-style of writing just makes it harder for newcomers who are not diehard comicbook fans to know what is happening. For example, the opening fight scene between the Cadre and Black Lightning could have been presented with more excitement and clarity. Instead, it looks like something the creators threw in just to meet a quota.

There is also a back feature that expands on the mystery of the Vixen's new powers. It helps move this storyline along but doesn't really reveal anything too impressive. The art is a clear imitation of Japan's manga style-- to the point of including some of the worst aspects of manga: the characters are too stylized with inappropriate facial expressions. Oh yes, Vixen does look really hot. She just doesn't look like Vixen.

As one of DC's flagship titles with dozens of characters popping in and out, the Justice League of America should really contain art that helps tell the story in a clear, comprehensive manner. Without it, this issue gets only two out of five stars-- which is shocking considering the talent involved.


Related Articles:
Justice League of America # 21
Justice League of America # 20
Justice League of America #19
Justice League International
Justice League: The New Frontier Special # 1
Justice League: The New Frontier
Justice League of America # 17
Justice League of America # 16
Justice League of America # 15
Justice League of America # 14



Comment Script Join the discussion:

Add a Comment

Comments


© Copyright 2002-2008, Coolstreak Cartoons Inc. - All rights Reserved. All other texts, images, characters and trademarks are copyright their respective owners. Use of material in this document(including reproduction, modification, distribution, electronic transmission or republication) without prior written permission is strictly prohibited.

Top of Page

Search

Batman #678
As soon as I figure out what's going on, I'm sure I'll love it.
Billy Batson and the Magic of SHAZAM # 1
Captain Marvel returns in new adventures aimed at kids of all ages.
Final Crisis # 2 (of 7)
One by one, the villains strike at the big names of DC comics.
Superman # 677
A new superbeing comes to Metropolis and he wants to take it for himself.
Trinity # 4
Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman battle a purple-people beater
DC Universe Special: Superman: Mongul
The best of Mongul-- that yellow b@$#@ard
Tor # 2 (of 6)
Tor, the caveman, faces both bizarre aliens and sabre-tooth tigers.
Fables: The Good Prince
Flycatcher, the janitor, discovers his destiny as The Good Prince.
Fables # 73: War & Pieces, Part One of Three
Fabletown finally strikes on the Homelands!
Justice Society of America #16
Who is this new god? And what does he want?
All Star Superman # 11
Superman faces imminent death while Luthor faces imminent execution.
Trinity # 1
Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman together at last! again...
Green Lantern # 31
Hal Jordan makes his first visit to Oa and encounters the rest of the Green Lantern Corps. in this re-telling of the Green Lantern origin.
Batman # 677
Batman lets his new lady love, Jezebel Jet into the Bat-cave as the evil Black Glove stage a crippling attack
The Brave and the Bold # 13
The original Flash, Jay Garrick shows up to save Batman’s hide, and the two heroes are soon embroiled in a mystery involving samurai robots!