JSA Series 1 – Larger Than Life Action Figures

By Hervé St-Louis
Aug 23, 2008 - 8:12

DC Direct has announced that it will release the first series of a new line of JSA action figures related to the new Justice Society of America comic book series released by DC Comics, last year. Of course, because Alex Ross painted the covers of the series, the action figures will also be modelled on Alex Ross’ work. The first characters spotlighted will be the Golden Age Green Lantern, the Golden Age Flash, the Sandman and Starman. At 7.5 inches, these action figures will be much larger than any other Justice Society action figure released in the past, and more in line with the scales used by DC Direct since 2005.

While the Golden Age Flash and Green Lantern have both been rendered twice as action figures by DC Direct, it will be the first time that action figures of the current Sandman (Sandy Hawkins) and the current Starman (Thom Kallor) are available. There have been two Sandman action figures in the past by DC Direct about Hawkins’ predecessor, Wesley Dodds released with two different paint schemes. There has also been two Starman action figures by DC Direct about the Golden Age Starman – Ted Knight, and his son Jack Knight.

Golden Age Green Lantern

The cases of Sandman and Starman bring out an interesting question about the commitment of DC Direct and parent company DC Comics about the work of critically acclaimed creators and the protection of their trademarks. Although the Sandman was owned by DC Comics, the version created by writer Neil Gaiman in 1989 was a not a super hero and was intended at the time as the definitive Sandman from DC Comics. DC Direct has also rendered this character, also known as Dream as an action figure, several times. Although many readers wanted it, Sandy Hawkins has not been called Sandman until recently out of concern for Neil Gaiman’s version.

Sandman

The same is true of Starman. After James Robinson created the new Starman comic book series and it ended publishing, the character of Jack Knight was not to be used in any story unless written by creator Robinson. So for years, two of the most important legacies at DC Comics, Starman and Sandman were tied up in publishing limbo because latter creators had created new versions of the characters deemed more important than the original and their sidekicks.

Golden Age Flash

Nevertheless, several writers at DC Comics, have been chipping and borrowing from the Gaiman and Robinson’s versions of Sandman and Starman to spruce up new versions of the characters, safe for publishing and merchandising! Hence, Stargirl, originally known as Star Spangle Kid, borrowed the power staff of Jack Knight. As for Sandy Hawkins, his new powers were partly inspired from Gaiman's Sandman.

I welcome the new versions of Sandman and Starman as they add up to the strong legacy of characters from DC Comics.

Starman

Now that the legacies of Sandman and Starman are re-established in the regular DC Comics’ universe, we have to deal with a most pressing issue which is the scale of the action figures. If you have collected Justice Society action figures from DC Direct since 2000, like I have, you’ll notice that they are not compatible with the new products from DC Direct. Here the vendor only repeats a pattern they have used for years to the dismay of many collectors. They are not interested in making all their lines and characters compatible with one another, unlike Marvel Toys’ Marvel Legend series. The more incongruous the action figures can be, the more they seem to enjoy it. Let’s face it. If you already own the first Golden Age Green Lantern and Flash action figures, why would you buy new ones, unless DC Comics made it hard for all those toys to look good in a display together?

Starman without mask

It’s hard to argue about the quality and beauty of these new action figures, but it’s hard to accept that that other action figures, which will never be recreated by DC Direct, like the Golden Age Hourman and the Golden Age Dr. Mid-nite will never look good next to a display of the current Justice Society.

Last Updated: May 16, 2012 - 6:56
Join the discussion:

Comment Script Join the discussion:

Comments

That's nonsense. SANDMAN MIDNIGHT THEATRE started while Sandman was going on, featuring the Golden Age Sandman. There's never been any agreement between me and DC about not using the name Sandman, and I'd wager the James Robinson stuff in your post is equally as based outside of reality. Where on earth do people get this stuff from?

#1 - Neil Gaiman - 08/23/2008 - 03:49

There is no nonsense here.

1-It is a known fact that Jack Knight cannot be used in a story without the consent of writer James Robinson. That's why we don't see Jack Knight in every issue of the Justice Society. If DC Comics could use the character, they would milk his appearances to death. You know that.

2-It took years for DC Comics to let Sandy Hawkins bear the name Sandman. It only happened last year in Justice Society of America #3. Go read any old message boards about DC Comics and the Justice Society and you will find comic book readers complaining that DC Comics refuses to let Sandy Hawkins bear the name Sandman.

3-That Sandman Mystery Theatre existed concurrently as the other Sandman series doesn't invalidate my argument. He was the original, remember? He's one of DC Comics' first characters. They can do with him what they want. Moreover, as I mentioned above, there has been two action figures based on the Golden Age Sandman, by DC Direct, modelled, oddly enough on the Sandman Mystery Theatre. The Sandman also appeared in several DC Comics series such as the first issue of JSA #1 in the last series, in 1999.

4-I could not verify that you are who you say you are. You left a fake email address. But if you really are Neil Gaiman, you should make sure that places like Wikipedia have their facts corrected before you come tell us that ours are not. I didn't use the Wikipedia entries as sources for this article. I only checked them out to see if my interpretation of facts was unique after your comments. Seems like Wikipedia (for all it's worth) shares my interpretation of history. But the Wikipedia entries have probably been, misinforming the public for years, if what you claim is true. I would focus on having them change their facts first.

5-I stand by what I wrote above, whether you truly are Neil Gaiman or not.

That's not Neil Gaiman.

Instead of being a ho and hiding behind another man's name to post so-called facts, the poster should be a man and use his own name.

#3 - Leroy Douresseaux - 08/24/2008 - 19:35

Hello. Here at the Comic Book Bin, we ask that writers and visitors communicate respectfully and refrain from personal attacks. There are ways of saying you disagree with a review without name calling.

RSS Mobile Comic Book Conventions Calendar Sending Press Releases Sending Review Material Job Advertising Terms of Service
Tweet