The Comic Book Bin
Comic Book Bin 
 
 Comics
 Comic Reviews
 Marvel Comics
 DC Comics (1339)
 Other Comics
 Back Issues
 Manga Reviews
 Comic News
 Spotlight
 Phil's Bubble
 European Comics
 Canuck
 Black Astronaut
 Comics 101
 Web Comics
 Comic Strips
 Religion and Comics
 
 Action Figures
 
 Video Games
 
 Fan Films
 
 Movies
 
 Books
 
 Interviews
 
 About
 Classifieds
 Newsletter
 RSS

 
Comics : Comic Reviews : DC Comics
Last Updated: Jun 19, 2009 - 18:32:39 PM




Birds of Prey #109
By Hervé St-Louis
Aug 22, 2007 - 21:34:26 PM

Email this article
 Printer friendly page

Add to Del.icio.us     Add To Reddit
Add To Digg     Add To Stumbleupon
Add To Technorati Favorites     Add To Ask


birdsofprey109.jpg
DC Comics
Writer: Tony Bedard
Artist: Nicola Scott
Inker: Doug Hazlewood

Barbara Gordon, the Oracle, wants to dissuade her best friend, Black Canary from accepting the marriage offer of Green Arrow. Barbara goes to length to show that Black Canary should not trust Green Arrow ever again. Meanwhile, someone is chasing New Gods, killing them one after the other. Is Big Barda, who comes from Apocalypse safe?

Bedard is the type of writer whose work looks good and concise after a first reading but which reveals all its weaknesses upon further reading. Here, I didn’t have to read the story a second time, before I figured that I should stay away from this comic book series, and others written Bedard. Trusted with the mantle of writing the Birds of Prey, and the upcoming Green Arrow and Black Canary wedding, puts Bedard in a sensitive position and gives him the opportunity to shine and show that he could be an A list writer.

But he fails totally to get past the obvious tricks of the trades. The only reason I picked up this issue, was because it was advertised as the tough talk that Black Canary should hear before marrying Green Arrow. Instead, it was lip service. Bedard, mentioned a few instances where Oliver Queen, Green Arrow cheated, but it did not feel like this was coming from Black Canary’s best friend. Instead, Barbara was like a bad actress reading a script and remembering what line to deliver next.

Many readers have opposed the union of Black Canary and Green Arrow. In the hands of a great writer, the voices and opinions of these readers would have come from the dialogues and advice of Barbara Gordon. The delivery was weak and without any conviction. Worse, it was difficult to understand why Black Canary was even mad at Gordon’s comments.

A proof of how Bedard’s writing does the minimum of work and effort in trying to convey a story, he mixes up the parentage of Oliver Queen’s sons. He mentions that Shado (that ninja chick) is the mother of Connor Hawke, Green Arrow’s eldest son. Shado is the mother of Oliver’s second son, not his first. Connor Hawke was born before Green Arrow was involved with Black Canary. Mike Carlin, a long time DC Comics’ editor who should know about things like that, let the mistake go uncorrected.

Scott is a good artist, except when it comes to drawing adult female faces. They have heavy cheekbones that make them look like men. The saving grace here, is that the two children in this story looked like girls.



Related Articles:
Birds of Prey #127
Birds of Prey # 111
Birds of Prey #109
Birds of Prey # 107
Birds of Prey # 106
Birds of Prey # 100
Birds of Prey #99
Birds of Prey # 98
Birds of Prey #97
Birds of Prey #96



Comment Script Join the discussion:

Add a Comment

Comments


© Copyright 2002-2009, Coolstreak Cartoons Inc. - All rights Reserved. All other texts, images, characters and trademarks are copyright their respective owners. Use of material in this document(including reproduction, modification, distribution, electronic transmission or republication) without prior written permission is strictly prohibited.

Top of Page

Final Crisis Aftermath: Run! # 3 (of 6)
The Human Flame, the loser supervillain who kicked off the Final Crisis, finds shelter with General Immortus but his bad luck and bad attitude continue to hound him.
Batman and Robin # 2
A rift develops between the new Batman and Robin as a new evil mastermind makes his appearance.
Justice League: Cry for Justice #1 (of 7)
The beginning of a DCU version of Marvel’s Civil War?
Greek Street #1
The Sopranos, meet Guy Richie, meet Sophocles. “These old stories aren’t through with us yet.”
Green Lantern #42
Hal Jordan and Larfleeze fight to a stalemate. Blackest Night marches closer.
Green Lantern Corps #37
Daxamites gain Superman-like abilities and planet Oa faces some serious trouble.
Superman #689
Mon El gets out of Metropolis for a while in order to see the world, and has plenty of encounters with various global heroes and villains.
Gotham City Sirens #1
Harley Quinn and Poison Ivy want Catwoman to reveal to them who Batman is
The Brave and the Bold # 24
Static and Black Lightning finally meet but the intrusion of the fiery villain Holocaust heats things up.
Action Comics Annual #12
The origin of Nightwing and Flamebird, Action Comics’ current headliners, is told, and it’s a tale not to be missed…
Final Crisis Aftermath: Dance # 2 (of 6)
The Super Young Team actually try to be superheroes while the evil corporation using them implements its dastardly scheme.
Outsiders #19
It's the Outsiders versus Deathstroke the Terminator as the team wants to prevent him from running away with the body of a slain man
Detective Comics #854
Batwoman makes her debut as the headliner of Detective Comics, and the verdict is…?
Green Arrow vs Black Canary #21
Green Arrow and Black Canary try to maintain order in the city, now that all sounds have been muted
Is Unwritten the Next DC Comics’ Vertigo Success?
The Unwritten is the story of Tom Taylor, the son of prolific author Wilson Taylor who created a character much like his son Tom in a series of books about a young wizard