The Comic Book Bin
Game Reviews (73) Articles


TopShelf Month

Darkhorse Month

Women's Month


Video Games : Game Reviews
Last Updated: Oct 20, 2009 - 7:25:21 AM



Review: Mirror's Edge
By Eli Green
Dec 16, 2008 - 17:30:00 PM

Studios: DICE
Publisher(s): Electronic Arts
Rating: T
Genre: Action, First-Person Platformer
Platform: Xbox 360, Playstation 3, PC
Players: 1
Email this Article
 Printer Friendly Page
 Mobile Friendly Page

Add to Del.icio.us     Add To Reddit
Add To Digg     Add To Stumbleupon
Add To Technorati Favorites     Add To Ask

mirrorsedge-360cover-250px.jpg
In a city where communications and information are locked down so tight that the news is really just advertising and civil unrest is punished with swift action, freedom of any sort is in constant question. Everything is monitored and controlled, down to the most minute details of citizens' daily lives, and most are not willing to fight back, don't care enough or don't remember how this came to pass. There are a select few people who won't stand suppression though, and they use runners as couriers for sensitive information. Traversing the cityscape like no one else can, runners use rooftops, sewers and any other accessible area to get the package to its destination, all while doing their best to stay out of harms way.

In Mirror's Edge you get to play as Faith, a runner who grew up during the civil unrest caused by the city's increasingly restricted information surveillance. You're given a decent introduction to Faith and the city – her parents would take Faith and her sister to rallies against the changes in the city when they were younger, but eventually they gave up, in her parent's case, or gave in, her sister joined the city's police force – and then the story unfolds as you play the game. When Faith's sister, Kate, is framed for the murder of Robert Pope, the mayoral candidate fighting to dismantle the city's communications surveillance, Faith is the only one who can help prove her sister's innocence. What she finds when trying to solve the mystery behind the murder though, is something far more sinister.

mirrorsedge-cranejump-450px.jpg

I definitely enjoyed the storyline in Mirror's Edge . Throughout each chapter, I was stuck to my seat, very much thanks to a combination of great gameplay and the involving story. You really get thrust into Faith's character and the world around her. She's not really trying to save the world, she just wants to survive. The circumstances she falls into just force her further into the story. That, and her love for her sister. I only had two issues with the storyline. First, I don't care how big a city is; if it's not a province/state or a whole country, a simple question like “Why don't you just move?” can really detract from the whole atmosphere. Second, there's too much sequel space. I really enjoyed the game and can't wait for the sequel, but there is such a thing as leaving too much space for a sequel, thus leaving a story unfinished. I could let those points bother me, but I enjoyed this game to much to let them do so.

Gameplay

This is first-person platforming done right. The development team deserves, and has received, major kudos for designing the control system for Mirror's Edge , because it was done so masterfully. First off, the controls are extremely simple. Once you take a close look at them, you'll realise that all the controls were intuitively mapped to allow you to do as many moves as possible, either simultaneously or in quick succession. This allows you to do an extremely complicated move, like going from a wall run to a jump across a gap, with relative ease (the more complicated moves will take some practice).

mirrorsedge-kick-450px.jpg

Like most first-person games out there, your movement and looking control is based around the analog control sticks. The left stick controls your forward, backward and strafing movement, while the right stick lets you look around in all directions. You can even look at your feet, which can be really helpful if you're having trouble timing your jumps. Unlike most first-person games though, your jumping and crouching aren't controlled by the buttons on the controller's face. Instead, the shoulder buttons and triggers control those moves – left button for jumping, left trigger for crouching, sliding or coiling during a jump, and right button for a quick 180 ° – and the right trigger also handles combat. This allows your right thumb to almost always stay on the right stick, which is key to being able to pull of a move like the wall run and gap jump I mentioned above. The only other controls are the Use/Interact button (A), the Disarm button (Y), the Reaction Time button (X) and the Hint button (B), which isn't so much of a hint as much as it is a compass.

Getting into the game itself, you're given a fully interactive tutorial in the runners' training Playground. Once you're done with the tutorial you can choose to mess around in the Playground or go straight to your missions, and the story begins. Soon enough you'll be running for your life, jumping over rooftop air conditioning units, grabbing onto pipes protruding from walls, running through various construction sites or any other number of areas of the city. And once your in, you'll be hooked.

The only problem with the story mode is that it's way too short. Don't get me wrong, the story is told very well and it flows, but the whole thing is just nine chapters, not including the prologue. The least they could have done is add in one or two regular missions before throwing you straight into the full storyline or make things more interesting by using the runner's base of operations as a starting point for each chapter, making it your job to get to the areas where all of the chapters currently start. That would also give you a better feel for the city a whole, rather than just a group of separated environments. On the flip side, some people may consider that option to be more boring, but at least it would make the game a little longer.

Truth be told though, Mirror's Edge is really about speed. If you wanted to, you could probably finish the entire game's story mode within 3 hours, give or take a few minutes for the cutscenes. And if speed is your thing, this game will have immense replay value, because outside of the story lies a Speed Run for each chapter of the story, as well as Time Trials based within the environments of each chapter. The Speed Runs are just a run through of the chapters with a timer, while the Time Trials are races with checkpoints. The cool thing about the Time Trials is that there can be multiple checkpoint setups for the same level, and you can race against your own ghost from your best time, so the replay value grows even more.

Multiplayer and Online

What game with racing elements would be complete without a good sense of competition? While Mirror's Edge does not have an actual multiplayer mode where you and your friends can play together either online or offline, you can still compete for the best times on each Speed Run and Time Trial. As long as your friends have accounts for the game, they can upload their times and you can race against their ghosts in the Time Trials. If you don't have any friends with the game, you can still try your hand against the world's fastest players and try to beat them or, at the very least, learn some of their moves. It's just a shame they didn't put ghosts into the Speed Runs as well.

Environment and Graphics

I'd like to apologize in advance to people who think I use the phrase “visually stunning” too often when describing the video games which I think look amazing, because Mirror's Edge is nothing but visually stunning. You'll feel fully immersed in the cityscape, and that's because it all looks so realistic. All of the buildings, railings, fences have a realistic feel to them, and it's only enhanced by the level of detail put into other things around the city like traffic (you'll have to look down from a long way up, but it's there), random debris floating in the wind and birds in flight.

mirrorsedge-stormdrainexit-450px.jpg

During one of my sessions with the game, Josh noted that one of the areas I was in looked far too bright. I might have been inclined to agree with him if I didn't think that the brightness added to the game's realism. If you're looking at something on a very bright day, shouldn't that thing, especially if it's a highly reflective or light reflective surface, like a solar panel or white wall, be very bright as well? The light is very different based on each level and the time of day. The problem I had with the game's lighting was with place where it changed for no reason, like elevators. The lighting in elevators should be constant unless the power goes out. There shouldn't be any moving light sources in an elevator unless, well, there actually is a moving light source.

The only thing that doesn't seem to change is the weather. It's always clear. For a game that takes place over such a short span of time though, it's not much of a concern. I would like to see what they could do with rain effects in the sequel though.

The character models are another graphics element that was extremely well done. They all look like real people and, even up close and personal, have very realistic attributes. There did seem to be a bit of an issue with lighting on the characters' faces when they spoke. That could have used some work.

Sound

They might have actually gone a little too realistic with the sounds in this one. Yes, the sounds of the city are great, not to mention very precise, and the sound effects for running on different surfaces are also quite well done. The different effects for things like helicopters, guns, breaking glass and voices when heard through radio communications area cool too, but, dear lord, the sound of Faith's bones crunching when you fall is just so spine chilling, especially after that rush you feel while watching the fall. From where I stand though, that means that all the sound effects in the game are great.

mirrorsedge-zipline-450px.jpg

The vocals were also very well done. It's always nice to see when someone does a good job of casting actors, voice or otherwise, and the casting for Mirror's Edge is no exception. Each of the voices fit their characters to a tea. My favourite out of all of them has to be Mercury (Merc), the leader of the runners. He's the gravelly, but unseen voice helping you along all your missions, but you can tell there's a specific attitude behind it; one of concern for the runners and of years of experience.

The music in the game is all original, and does a great job of accompanying the gameplay. I'm not a fan of techno or electronic music, for the most part, and I probably wouldn't listen to the soundtrack outside the game, but you can't knock a good fit. The music balanced perfectly with the atmosphere in each level, and with chase sequences as well. I've got no complaints with any part of the sound in this game.

Conclusion

Mirror's Edge finally proves that first-person platforming is possible, when done right. With a great control scheme, amazing visuals and an awesome soundtrack, Mirror's Edge is a fully immersive experience that will keep you glued to your seat. While the story could have been longer, this game has so much replay value it will keep you interested for weeks, and the upcoming downloadable content should keep you entertained for even longer.


Gameplay: 10
Environment and Graphics: 8.5
Sound: 10
Story: 8
Fun: 9.5

Verdict: Buy It



Related Articles:
EA and DICE Release Mirror's Edge Time Trial Pack
Review: Mirror's Edge
DLC Coming For Mirror's Edge
EA Ships Mirror's Edge, FaceBreaker K.O. Party
Mirror's Edge Demo Online This Week
Mirror's Edge Dated For Release


Comment Script Join the discussion:

Add a Comment

Comments

Great review for a great game. I wish you had mentioned the comic book tie-in.
#1 - Avi - 12/19/2008 - 00:49
Could not be further from the truth
Other than getting a 10/10 for originality, this game doesn't deserve a 10 (let alone a 9.5 for fun). This is the most frustrating game i have ever played on any console.

Any game where you die, play, die, play, die, play, die, play, die, play, ohhh - I'm supposed to go there... finally, pass the chapter - sucks.

Verdict: Rent it and get ready for a session of anger management.
#2 - Zvi Woolf - 02/16/2009 - 18:52
That's a bit unfair. I think you might have done well to use the direction button when lost instead of simply jumping off random ledges and roofs until you found the right one.
#3 - Eli Green - 02/17/2009 - 15:00
Could not be further from the truth (cont.)
Hey Eli:

I was using the direction button, and still died too many times. Honestly... when you rank a game 10 out of 10, you are stating that the game is PERFECT and there is nothing developers need to do to make it better... Do you really believe that?

Games like GTA4, Gears of War 2, Halo's, COD4, NHL09... I wouldn't give them a 10 out of 10, (but they would be placed extremely close to that score - 9 to 9.5ish).

Mirror's Edge is a 7.5 at best, and is only deserving of a pat on the back for one of the best original games on the 360 - but that's it.

On another note: You should send me your gamertag and join our Wednesday night group... let me know if you have my email address.

Z
#4 - Zvi Woolf - 03/02/2009 - 14:36
Gamertag
Hey Zvi,

My gamertag is, astonishingly, Comic Book Bin. Hehe.

I do believe the game received a 10 for gameplay. It's an opinion, remember? That's my opinion.
#5 - Eli Green - 03/03/2009 - 18:49
hey Eli - nothing personal... i respect your opinion (i just don't agree with it) :)

I'll add you in as a buddy... what games do you like playing online?
#6 - Zvi - 03/19/2009 - 10:09


© Copyright 2002-2009, Coolstreak Cartoons Inc. - All rights Reserved. All other texts, images, characters and trademarks are copyright their respective owners. Use of material in this document(including reproduction, modification, distribution, electronic transmission or republication) without prior written permission is strictly prohibited.



Top of Page

Review: The Ballad of Gay Tony
Despite some dated graphics, this addition to the already massive sand box game is very welcomed.
Review: Halo 3: ODST
With great visuals, audio and addictive multiplayer mode, this game is a great addition to the series.
Review: The Beatles: Rock Band
Harmonix keeps delivering a new experience each time. This game is an absolute must have for Beatles fans and music lovers alike.
Review: Wii Sports Resort
The incredible 1:1 controls and enjoyable gameplay make this the best mini game collection on the console.
Splosion Man
A great and funny game that utilizes some of the hardest platforming stages imaginable.
Review: Halo Wars: Historic Battles
A great set of new maps for any die hard fan of the series but doesn't offer enough new content to make it a necessity.
Review: Gears of War 2: All Fronts Collection
A great price point for a wealth of new and fun content.
Review: The Conduit
A unique control scheme can't save this bland and boring first-person shooter.
Review: Call of Juarez: Bound in Blood
A game that comes so close to being a good buy falls just short and feels like a massive tech demo.
Review: Bit. Trip Core
A new control scheme is welcomed to the franchise's great retro look and sound.
Review: LifeSigns: Hospital Affairs
The awkward pacing and long dialogue moments cause LifeSigns to feel weighed down and quite boring.
Review: Zen Pinball
I'd Rather Meditate
Review: Rhythm Heaven
A great game with enough music and diversity to get into anyone's good books, as long as they are up for some practice.
Review: Pokemon Platinum
It creates a unique and engaging world to spend loads of time exploring, but remains too similar to past games in the series.
Review: Halo Wars
Getting past the awkward pacing and simplistic gameplay can lead to some intense and great fun with Halo Wars.