The Comic Book Bin
DCDirect (206) Articles


TopShelf Month

Darkhorse Month

Women's Month


Action Figures : DCDirect
Last Updated: Oct 20, 2009 - 7:25:21 AM



Watchmen Action Figures – Controversies and Fulfilment
By Hervé St-Louis
Aug 18, 2008 - 6:34:18 AM

Email this Article
 Printer Friendly Page
 Mobile Friendly Page

Add to Del.icio.us     Add To Reddit
Add To Digg     Add To Stumbleupon
Add To Technorati Favorites     Add To Ask

In anticipation of the 2009 Watchmen film adaptation by Warner Brothers Studios, DC Direct, the merchandising arm of comic book publisher DC Comics, has announced a series of action figures and statuettes matching the look of the film to be released between January and March 2008, just before the release of the movie. However, this is not the first time that DC Direct has tried to release Watchmen merchandise. What has changed that has made this specific release possible this time?

watchmentoys3.jpg


At the 2000 San Diego Comic-Con, DC Direct announced that they would release action figures of Dr. Manhattan, Silk Spectre, and the Comedian to coincide with the 15th anniversary of the Watchmen comic book series published in 1986-7. Although prototypes were shown at the convention, soon after DC Direct announced that they were cancelling the Watchmen action figures. Alan Moore, the writer of Watchmen had expressed disapproval of the action figures and other promotional efforts related to the anniversary of the comic book series.

watchmenbusts.jpg


In previous years, Moore had a disagreement with DC Comics over the payment of what the publisher called promotional items. Moore argued that the buttons were not promotional items and that royalties should be paid for them. It is possible that this episode and the stated intent of Moore to refuse any work or direct relationship with DC Comics, soured the DC Direct action figures release of 2001. DC Comics does own the Watchmen completely, but it seems that Moore’s approval was still needed to make derivative products.

watchmenbust2.jpg


Often creators who have sold their properties to other parties retain moral rights to oversee and approve how derivative products are generated from their work. Moral rights are not economic rights that afford creators any income, but they have an unlimited veto over how their work is used, even if they do not own it.

watchmentoys.jpg


The strategy used for the Watchmen action figures announced recently is different and may have offered DC Direct an opportunity to bypass Alan Moore’s approval. The vendor clearly markets the action figures as Watchmen Movie Action Figures. Moore does not want to be associated at all with the film or claim any royalties due and thus would have no artistic moral copyrights over any merchandise related to the Watchmen film.

watchmentoys2.jpg


Although collectors were disappointed when DC Direct cancelled the first Watchmen action figures, the ones from the film will more than make up for the initial loss. Because the characters, designs have been improved for realism, the action figures look more dynamic and much better than the original ones shown in 2000. In the end, waiting eight more years paid off for action figures collectors who wanted Watchmen toys!


Related Articles:
From Comic Book to film: A late salute for The Watchmen
Ray Wall Band's Watchmen Song
Saturday Morning Watchmen
DC's After Watchmen What's Next?
Watchmen: Not as Strong as Predicted at Box Office
Watchmen Refreshed
Watchmen The Movie: Review
About This Movie: Watchmen
Watching the Watchmen: Rorschach
Watching the Watchmen: Dr. Manhattan


Comment Script Join the discussion:

Add a Comment

Comments

Boo
I'm not sure how these new figures, so "awesome", just like the upcoming Watchmen movie, are any kind of improvement over the 2000 figures that looked, believe it or not, just like the Dave Gibbons-designed, classic characters in the original work.
#1 - Crooked - 08/18/2008 - 22:18
Whether the originals were cool or not, Alan Moore doesn't want the original prototype to be released as toys. So I take what I can get!
#2 - Hervé St-Louis - 08/19/2008 - 01:35
it is about time DCD
all i have to say is it is about damn time you released these heros...this book is only the most celebrated graphic novel of all f&$%ing time DC...I mean does this company like to make money? I guess not or they would have released these in a set long before there was a movie.
#3 - Ryan - 12/17/2008 - 09:43
Nite Owl
So some people think it's controversial that the Nite Owl figure doesn't have a belly... :-P
#4 - watchmen action figure - 01/04/2009 - 01:19


© Copyright 2002-2009, Coolstreak Cartoons Inc. - All rights Reserved. All other texts, images, characters and trademarks are copyright their respective owners. Use of material in this document(including reproduction, modification, distribution, electronic transmission or republication) without prior written permission is strictly prohibited.



Top of Page

Get Your Color Corps Rings
Fans of the Color Corps need to pre-order a selected set of books to ensure they get a full set of these limited edition rings.
G'nort
G'nort is finally rendered as an action figure
Justice League International Black Canary
It's amazing that an action figure of a version of a character’s costume many people dislike was approved
Justice League International Ice
There has been Mattel action figures of Ice, but this is the first one by DCDirect
JLI Batman
Artist Kevin Maguire help work on the designs of the Batman action figure based on the popular Justice League International
Watchmen's Ozymandias
In the comic books, Ozymandias always appeared a bit more plastic and perfect than other characters
Watchmen's Modern Nite Owl
The modern Nite Owl action figure is based on the movie version of the character appearing in the comic book series The Watchmen
Rorschach Action Figure Doesn't Please
I’m not happy about this new Rorschach action figure based on the movie version of the character
10 Years of Collecting DCDirect Action Figures: The Early Years
The first years from 1998 to 2000
JSA Series 1 – Larger Than Life Action Figures
DC Direct has announced that it will release the first series of a new line of JSA action figures related to the new Justice Society of America based on Alex Ross' work
Hawkgirl’s Wings – Don't Let Me Down
Kendra Saunders, the new Hawkgirl, is a reincarnation of the first Hawkgirl who teamed up with Hawkman and the Justice Society in the Golden Age. However, this Hawkgirl is nothing like her late aunt and nobody's sidekick.
Watchmen Action Figures – Controversies and Fulfilment
Although the first Watchmen action figures were cancelled, collectors get another chance at getting them, just in time for the upcoming film.
Jonah Hex DC Direct Review
A review of Jonah Hex action figure, DC Comics' Western maverick and time traveller, by DC Direct
Golden Age Hourman
Hourman, the man of the hour, only had to take a Miraclo pill to gain super powers for one hour. But if you're one of the lucky one who owns a copy of his only action figure, you'll have a treasure for eternity!
Bowen Batman On Gargoyle
Before props and action figures of super heroes were popular staples at comic book stores and other novelty retailers, the ancestor of what collectors know as DC Direct released a Batman statue of Batman sitting on top of a gargoyle that was sculpted by Randy Bowen in 1991