The Comic Book Bin
Canuck (78) Articles


TopShelf Month

Darkhorse Month

Women's Month


 
Comics : Canuck
Last Updated: Oct 20, 2009 - 7:25:21 AM




The Gwaii #1
By Hervé St-Louis
Mar 28, 2009 - 9:20:23 AM

Publisher(s): Arcana Studios
Writer(s): Sean O'Reilly
Penciller(s): The Great LP
Inker(s): The Great LP
Colourist(s): The Great LP
Letterer(s): Shawn Depasquale
Cover Artist(s): The Great LP
99 cents US
Email this Article
 Printer Friendly Page
 Mobile Friendly Page

Add to Del.icio.us     Add To Reddit
Add To Digg     Add To Stumbleupon
Add To Technorati Favorites     Add To Ask


The Gwaii is about a band of sasquatches living in a remote island in British Columbia. When Taanuu’s mother is shot at and caught, à la Bambi’s mom by hunters, Taanuu decides that he will rescue his mother.  Helping him on his quest is Jaada, a young female sasquatch. But time is running and the humans are not about to let two young Sasquatches ruin their logging plant. Will Taanuu save his mom before it’s too late?

This series was clearly marketed for kids and licensors. That’s all good an fine, but the attractive price point can’t hide the fact that there are many problems with this simple tale. The story is not meant to be complicated and easy to pick up by any reader. The problem is that making a story simple and easy to pick up doesn’t mean it has to be dumb down. Kids are not stupid and writing down at them is not the way to catch their interest. When I was a kid, I liked those cartoons and comic books that did not emphasis the fact that they were written for a younger audience.

The story itself has severe plot inconsistencies. First, Taanuu’s mom did not have to attack the hunters. She and her son could have gotten away quickly as they had not been discovered. That she was willing to attack them broke the covenant, mentioned mere pages before that the Gaii always try to hide from humans.  Of course, had she not done so, there would have been no story to be told, except for one of happy sasquatches living in a forest.

the_gwai1.jpg


For a tale that emphasis native values, Taanuu and the other sasquatches sure sound like your average suburbanite. Hence there is no attempt to infuse real native tones and perspective in this story, save for using native names. The native names are also a problem. The character’s name and even the name Gwaii is written with different spelling within the comic book, but also on Arcana’s Web site. It is Gwai or Gwaii? Is it Taanuu or Tanu. This is simple editing issue that should have been figured out before releasing and promoting the comic book.

Visually, the designs are quite interesting. The sasquatches are very reminiscent of the Tasmanian devil! However, there is again inconsistencies with the size relation of the sasquatches and their environment. Are these creatures bigger than humans or small cartoon-sized characters?

Rating: 4/10


Related Articles:
Sasquatch



Comment Script Join the discussion:

Add a Comment

Comments


© Copyright 2002-2009, Coolstreak Cartoons Inc. - All rights Reserved. All other texts, images, characters and trademarks are copyright their respective owners. Use of material in this document(including reproduction, modification, distribution, electronic transmission or republication) without prior written permission is strictly prohibited.

Top of Page

WestJet's Bad Customer Service
Why does Westjet take credit when employees make them look good and rejects the blame when it makes them look bad?
Jan's Atomic Heart
One of the best 6$ I have spent at a small publisher this year.
True Loves vol.1
A very good romance comic book that should please everyone.
Captain Canuck vol.1
Terrorists and criminals of all kind beware! Captain Canuck and his acolytes are back in this first volume reprinting issues #4-10 of the original adventures of this Canadian comic book icon
The Palm Pre’s Poor French – Le Palm Pré coule son français
Palm, like many other companies, such Apple, Adobe and Microsoft often uses poor French in its products
Fan Expo Gallery
A gallery of last weekend's Fan Expo in Toronto showing the diversity of the city and its comic book convention.
State of Canadian Comic Books Debate
Surveying the landscape of Canadian comics at the Word on the Street Toronto festival
Jeff Lemire's Sweet Tooth #1
A boy with antlers; he's the "sweet" of this title.
Montreal Comic-Con
The Montreal Comic-Con will be held on the weekend of September 19th-20th, 2009
Jungle Tales #1
An homage to the jungle girls of the Golden Age.
I'm crazy
An autobiographical tale about love, humanity and mental illness.
Jaywalking in Montreal - A Special Feature
The art of jaywalking in Montreal with style explained by an expatriate from Montreal
Does Canada Need a Master Cartoonist Like Doug Wright?
The notion of a Canadian master cartoonist, like Doug Wright imposes a rigid cast system that shuts off any debate about Canadian comic book arts
The Collected Doug Wright Vol. 1
Doug Wright doesn't deserve to be called Canada's master cartoonist and he is not the equivalent of Charles Schulz
Toronto Comic Arts Festival Endorsed by Liberal's Bob Rae
Bob Rae requests no apologies from Doug Wright Awards for discriminatory practices