The Comic Book Bin
Phil's Bubble (147) Articles


TopShelf Month

Darkhorse Month

Women's Month


 
Comics : Phil's Bubble
Last Updated: Oct 20, 2009 - 7:25:21 AM




How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love Comics Again
By Philip Schweier
Jan 16, 2007 - 6:10:33 AM

Email this Article
 Printer Friendly Page
 Mobile Friendly Page

Add to Del.icio.us     Add To Reddit
Add To Digg     Add To Stumbleupon
Add To Technorati Favorites     Add To Ask


How often it has been said the sense of wonder we experience as children is lost as we mature. I'd like to believe I've overcome that problem, but other people probably know better.

bravebold108.jpg
Nevertheless, when I was a mere lad of eight or nine, it never bothered me to see Batman having self-contained adventures in so many titles: Detective Comics, Batman, Brave & the Bold, World's Finest and Justice League. Later there was Batman Family, Legends of the Dark Knight, and a host of others.

It's inevitable that the most popular characters are going to be appearing in multiple titles. Wolverine has his own book, as well as being an X-Man and an Avenger. For someone who has a reputation for being something of a loner, maybe he's being spread a bit thin. Greg Rucka had the right idea when he was writing the first few issues of Wolverine, that those stories took place between X-Men adventures.

Which is how most readers regarded the old self-contained stories of 1970s. Once in a while, there might be a reference to what had come before. Usually, it amounted to our hero facing the surprise villain: "You! I thought you were DEAD!" And then the editor would refer us  to a story from 30 or 40 issues ago.

action535.jpg
But then a funny thing happened; comics grew up, and so did we. Somewhere around 1983, I was reading Action Comics, at the time written by Marv Wolfman and drawn by Gil Kane. In battle with Satanus, Superman was divided in two, his powers cut in half. This same run of Action Comics introduced The Omega Men, who then moved on to guest star in the pages of Teen Titans, also written by Wolfman.

But when Superman introduced the Omega Men to Robin and the gang, he commented on being at half-power, and I remember thinking, "Well, yeah, why not? And how come he's not at 50 percent in Superman, DC Comics Presents, and Justice League?" I really felt someone had dropped the ball in terms of continuity.

In the years since, it has pleased me to see continuity become a stabilizing thread throughout the various comics universes. I felt that some of the creative chaos was being reigned in. But sometimes too much of a good thing is a bad thing.

comics-code-stamp.jpg
Remember the advent of the Comics Code Authority? Well, neither do I, not having been born. But they essentially laid some ground rules regarding what was suitable in comics aimed at children. It seemed like a good idea at the time, but some of the lengths to which they went were excessive. For instance, they had a rule against showing women in bondage. Near-nekkid slaves in chains, sure, I understand. But this also meant that if Lois Lane was captured by the villain du jour, he¹d better have a freezo-ray or something. If he was forced to do things the old fashioned way, and tied Lois to a chair, that consitutes bondage, and the Comics Code Authority wouldn't have it.

Like I said, a reasonable idea taken to excess. Just like continuity in recent years.
Perhaps the solution isn't continuity, but CONSISTENCY. What's the difference? Well, having Bruce Wayne drive a Porsche in one comic, and a Jaguar in another might be regardedby some anal-retentive know-nothings as a continuity violation. But given his wealth, it reasonable to assume he has multiple high-end automobiles available. So it's at least consistent.

spider-man100.jpg
I'll grant you that perhaps that something of a nitpicky detail, but such is the extreme nature of the self-appointed Continuity Police ­ which is why I suggest that we all just loosen up a bit and relax. Not everyone who writes a certain character is going to tell a story the same way, but unless the voice of that character fails to ring true, I'd have to say we're all on the same page. As long as Spider-Man is the same wise-cracking web-head we all know and love, what's the problem?

Characterization should be consistent, and the titles can be used as a venue for the type of story told. Action Comics can be just that: emphasis on action. The Superman title can be more character-driven, exploring the "Man" of Steel.

True continuity is found by remaining true to the characters and concepts as they have evolved over the years. Not every detail in a story need relate directly to something that has come before. If it did, how would you explain that Bruce Wayne hasn't seemed to age much, whereas Dick Grayson has grown from a pre-teen circus boy to an adult Nightwing?

In the film Field of Dreams, actor Ray Liotta, portrayed baseball player Shoeless Jo Jackson. Liotta suggested he learn to pitch and catch left-handed, as the real Shoeless Jo Jackson did, to add a degree of authenticy to the movie. Director Phil Alden Robinson then pointed out that a bigger flaw in the film in terms of authenticy is that Shoeless Jo Jackson was DEAD!

My point is that some things in the world of fiction should simply be taken on faith. Realism and accuracy are fluid, and subject to the immediate story at hand. Minute details shouldn't be allowed to detract from the overall experience of the narrative. Otherwise, why read comics in the first place? Babies don't come from Krytpon, radioactive spider bites will not give a person spider-like abilities, and people don't run around cities wearing tights and a mask, fighting crime.



Related Articles:
Hawkman's Continuity Explained
Continuity and the Doom Patrol
Crisis in the Infinite Continuity



Comment Script Join the discussion:

Add a Comment

Comments


© Copyright 2002-2009, Coolstreak Cartoons Inc. - All rights Reserved. All other texts, images, characters and trademarks are copyright their respective owners. Use of material in this document(including reproduction, modification, distribution, electronic transmission or republication) without prior written permission is strictly prohibited.

Top of Page

Comics, Kids and the Creation of Galaxy Man
Atlanta area comic book store owner, and his creation that brings hope to the galaxy.
'Tis the Season...
Wanna see something REALLY scary? So would I.
Collecting Comics
It's one thing to be an avid comic book reader, but collecting can present a whole new world of challenges.
The Costumes of Dragon*Con
A lot of cons feature costuming, but nobody does it like Dragon*Con!
Celluloid Heroes
There's always a lot of gritting of teeth when translating comics to film, from the original creator on down the line.
That '70s Super-hero
The 1970s was a time of rampant super-heroes on the small screen, some say paving the way for Star Wars. Let's take a look.
The Joy of Collecting
Rebuilding a collection better than before takes time and technology, but above all it takes passion.
Timeless Heroes
Comic books have the advantage of being set in any time period. But are mainstream super-heroes limited to the here-and-now? Or is that Elseworlds?
Basic Instructions: How to Shop for Back Issues
Shopping for back issues can be so frustrating, it can move a collector to tears.
Leaving Well Enough Alone
Popular characters should have a timeless appeal,but does that mean they should always be contemporary?
Do You Want It Right or Do You Want It Right Now?
Which should come first, maintaining a monthly schedule, or maintaining the highest quality? Here's a possible solution.
My Big Fat Geek Accomplishment
Collectors love their collections, and achieving a goal is (sometimes) worth announcing.
Long Live the Legion!
With the Legion Crisis series winding down, and the Legion of Super-Heroes poised for new greatness, here's a quick rundown of its history in the DC Universe.
Retro Review: Dick Tracy (1990)
Dick Tracy was just the kind of hero America needed during the gangster era. While our heroes have become more super, there's still some life in the old boy yet.
Behind the Scenes With The Plaid Avenger
Comics as a teaching tool? Nothing new, but on a college level, if you're not careful, you just might learn something.