Comics / Comic Reviews / More Comics

Mata Hari

By Andy Frisk
September 9, 2010 - 10:19

Femme Fatale? Traitor? Scapegoat? Mata Hari was all of these and perhaps more. Born Margaretha Geertruida Zolle, the woman who would become Mata Hari (Indonesian for “sun” or “eye of the day”) would also become known as the spy who was the direct cause of the death of 50,000 allied soldiers during World War I. The spectacular failure of the Allied/French Spring Offensive of 1917 was rather due, possibly, to the ineptitude of the offensive’s commander, General Nivelle, instead of passed pillow talk obtained by alleged double agent Mata Hari. Mata Hari’s guilt or innocence, and likely status as a sacrificial scapegoat for the offensive’s failure, are facts that historians have been attempting to justify one way or the other for decades. The truth won’t be known, again possibly, until the sealed documents pertaining to Mata Hari’s case are opened in 2017, exactly 100 years from the time of her trial, conviction, and execution. As Mata Hari author Richard Wilkes argues, there must be a reason these documents were ordered sealed for such a long period of time. Often times, faced with defeat, near revolution in the ranks, and a grueling battle for survival, placing the blame for a major national and military failure upon the shoulders of someone (or some group) of perceived low morals, like an entertainer of Mata Hari’s type, rather than allowing it to rest upon the incompetent shoulders of the guilty party is the only way to rally a nation (or ruling group) of people to turn back from the brink. According to Wilkes, and many historians, this was the case with Mata Hari.


Mata Hari sets the stage for a speculative imagining in sequential art form of the true tale of Mata Hari’s life, lifestyle, and position as either the ultimate femme fatale or innocent scapegoat. Taking what Wilkes himself describes as “extreme liberties” with Mata Hari and General Nivelle’s histories, Wilkes is setting the stage for a tragic tale of incompetence and injustice with Mata Hari at the center. The liberties Wilkes takes with Mata Hari’s story appear to be possible. It’s an interesting alternative to the story told by those writing the history of the time period. The same ones who tried, convicted, and executed Mata Hari for a crime that she might have been completely unqualified and unable to perform.


Framing this revisionist and speculative alternate history of Mata Hari’s story within the tale of a young Russian girl who discovers documents that tell an interesting story amongst her dead uncle’s belongings, allows Wilkes to set the stage and provide a basis for launching into a revision of Mata Hari’s story. He does a great job introducing Mata Hari, the historical figure, to his readers as well as laying the basis for his version of her tale as a scapegoat for the failed Spring Offensive of 1917. Artist Roy Allen Martinez and colorist/painter Drazenka Kimpel manage to give vivid and striking, as well as imaginative, life to Wilkes’ introduction of his version of the truth of Mata Hari’s life, and its untimely end. They manage to convey the seductive look and talents of Mata Hari and her stage show while providing a striking visual history lesson of World War I and its effect on world geopolitics and culture that extends into contemporary times.


Overall, Mata Hari #0, as it is technically labeled, is a strong work of sequential art that stands well on its own, but does a fantastic job of enticing its readers to look forward to this alternative take on one of history’s most desired and reviled, yet potentially innocent, female criminals. Like most books published by Radical Publications, Mata Hari #0 and the forth coming (Spring 2011) Mata Hari “128 page, full color, hardcover graphic novel” both look to be tailor made to be adapted to the big screen ( I picture Mila Kunis in the title role—okay, so I’ve got a minor star crush on her). Based upon the quality of Mata Hari #0, and the peek it gives us into the potential quality of the graphic novel, it’s one book that should scream “film adaptation,” and rightly so.

Rating: 9 /10

Last Updated: January 24, 2022 - 11:00

    RSS       Mobile       Contact        Advertising       Terms of Service    ComicBookBin

© Copyright 2002-2022, Toon Doctor Inc. - All rights Reserved. All other texts, images, characters and trademarks are copyright their respective owners. Use of material in this document (including reproduction, modification, distribution, electronic transmission or republication) without prior written permission is strictly prohibited. Toon Doctor ® is registered trademarks of Toon Doctor Inc. Privacy Policy