The Comic Book Bin
Phil's Bubble (147) Articles


TopShelf Month

Darkhorse Month

Women's Month


 
Comics : Phil's Bubble
Last Updated: Oct 20, 2009 - 7:25:21 AM




Batman R.I.P.-off
By Philip Schweier
Mar 7, 2009 - 19:41:07 PM

Email this Article
 Printer Friendly Page
 Mobile Friendly Page

Add to Del.icio.us     Add To Reddit
Add To Digg     Add To Stumbleupon
Add To Technorati Favorites     Add To Ask


Final Crisis #7 has been almost a month now, so people have had ample time to read it. Those that haven’t probably aren’t interested, and most have  likely heard about the final teaser image from one Web site or another already.

batman681.jpg
The last panel shows an aged cave dweller, supposedly Anthro, the First Boy, in his old age, resting comfortably. By his side is Batman, who supposedly had died at the hands of Darkseid in Final Crisis #6. He was supposed to die in the final issue chapter of Batman R.I.P. ( Batman #681). However, it seems to be DC Comics policy these days to feature a story ending in a completely different comic book than expected.

Instead, Batman met his end, caught in a deadman’s play between Darkseid’s death beams. We never actually see them hit, but a page or so  later, Superman is shown carrying the burned out husk of what appears to be Batman. Well, the corpse is wearing the bat-costume, anyway.

However, in the aforementioned final panel of Final Crisis, a figure deep in shadow is scrawling a bat symbol on a cave wall next to Anthro. Some might suggest that since we don’t see his face, it’s not conclusively Batman, but DC Editor-in-chief Dan DiDio has confirmed that it is.

Was DC Comics ever going to kill off Batman? No, child, it wasn’t.  Don’t be naive. While I’ve not had solid confirmation from its editorial management, logic suggests DC Comics has been yanking our chain the whole time.

Deathofsuperman.jpg
Let’s go back several years to the Death of Superman storyline. Mainstream media ran with it, almost as if the intent was in fact to kill Superman and stop publishing what is arguably one of the most recognized fictional characters in the world. The money wrapped up in licensing and toys and film is far too great for that to ever happen.

And of course, the Man of Steel returned to fight another day.

But perhaps DC Comics’ plan wasn’t to kill Batman, per se, but Bruce Wayne, and have someone else take over the Batman identity. Not likely, and here’s why: for the past several years, DC Comics has been rebuilding the classic second- and third-tier characters. Oliver Queen, as Green Arrow, died and was replaced by Connor Hawke; now Oliver’s back. Hal Jordan, as Green Lantern, turned evil, died and became the Spectre. Kyle Rayner became Green Lantern, but Hal Jordan was reborn. Barry Allen, as Flash, died during the original Crisis, and his sidekick Wally West assumed the Flash identity. Barry returned during the "recent unpleasantness."

detective366.jpg
Would DC Comics go to the trouble of resurrecting such classic characters, only to end Bruce Wayne and replace him with Dick Grayson or Jason Todd? It seems like a bad idea to me.

!!

Okay, moving along. Perhaps Bruce (Batman) Wayne will return in some time-travel story. I’m guessing all will be revealed sometime in the next 18 months or so. By that time, given DC Comics’ recent track-record of red-herrings, disinformation and over-blown hype, I have to wonder if anyone will even care.

Praise and adulation? Scorn and ridicule? E-mail me at philip@comicbookbin.com.



Related Articles:
Superman/Batman #65
Blackest Night: Batman # 3 (of 3)
Superman/Batman: Public Enemies
The State of Batman: The Dark Knight and Batman in Barcelona
Batman and Robin # 2
Batman #687
Batman in Barcelona: Dragon's Knight # 1 (of 1)
Batman and Robin #1
Batman: Battle for the Cowl #3 (of 3)
Batman: Battle for the Cowl-- the Network # 1 (of 1)



Comment Script Join the discussion:

Add a Comment

Comments

Couldn't agree more...
Technically, Batman isn't dead. He's off somewhere in some reality living through the "Omega Sanction" or some such nonsense. Death of Superman was great as it wasn't done before to that extent of great storytelling, to me at least, but this whole Batman thing reeks of ripoff. Right on...
#1 - Andy - 03/07/2009 - 23:32
Good points
Thanks for putting this out there, Phil-- it needs to be said.

I get the sense that D.C. did mean to kill Bruce Wayne, but chickened out when they realized how badly it would alienate fans. They still, however, are going to sell all that "Battle for the Cowl" crap, because D.C. (or Marvel, to be fair) can't resist a meta-storyline.

On a side note: I felt D.C. was ripping off the Death of Captain America storyline more with Batman R.I.P. It worked for Marvel, so why not just copy...
#2 - Geoff - 03/09/2009 - 20:56

© Copyright 2002-2009, Coolstreak Cartoons Inc. - All rights Reserved. All other texts, images, characters and trademarks are copyright their respective owners. Use of material in this document(including reproduction, modification, distribution, electronic transmission or republication) without prior written permission is strictly prohibited.

Top of Page

Comics, Kids and the Creation of Galaxy Man
Atlanta area comic book store owner, and his creation that brings hope to the galaxy.
'Tis the Season...
Wanna see something REALLY scary? So would I.
Collecting Comics
It's one thing to be an avid comic book reader, but collecting can present a whole new world of challenges.
The Costumes of Dragon*Con
A lot of cons feature costuming, but nobody does it like Dragon*Con!
Celluloid Heroes
There's always a lot of gritting of teeth when translating comics to film, from the original creator on down the line.
That '70s Super-hero
The 1970s was a time of rampant super-heroes on the small screen, some say paving the way for Star Wars. Let's take a look.
The Joy of Collecting
Rebuilding a collection better than before takes time and technology, but above all it takes passion.
Timeless Heroes
Comic books have the advantage of being set in any time period. But are mainstream super-heroes limited to the here-and-now? Or is that Elseworlds?
Basic Instructions: How to Shop for Back Issues
Shopping for back issues can be so frustrating, it can move a collector to tears.
Leaving Well Enough Alone
Popular characters should have a timeless appeal,but does that mean they should always be contemporary?
Do You Want It Right or Do You Want It Right Now?
Which should come first, maintaining a monthly schedule, or maintaining the highest quality? Here's a possible solution.
My Big Fat Geek Accomplishment
Collectors love their collections, and achieving a goal is (sometimes) worth announcing.
Long Live the Legion!
With the Legion Crisis series winding down, and the Legion of Super-Heroes poised for new greatness, here's a quick rundown of its history in the DC Universe.
Retro Review: Dick Tracy (1990)
Dick Tracy was just the kind of hero America needed during the gangster era. While our heroes have become more super, there's still some life in the old boy yet.
Behind the Scenes With The Plaid Avenger
Comics as a teaching tool? Nothing new, but on a college level, if you're not careful, you just might learn something.