Comic Book Bin 
 
 Comics
 Comic Reviews
 Manga Reviews
 Comic News
 Spotlight (238)
 Phil's Bubble
 European Comics
 Canuck
 Black Astronaut
 Comics 101
 Web Comics
 Comic Strips
 
 Action Figures
 
 Video Games
 
 Fan Films
 
 Movies
 
 Books
 
 Interviews
 
 About
 Classifieds
 Newsletter
 RSS

Comics : Spotlight
Last Updated: Aug 21, 2008 - 6:44:20 AM



Am I Buying Trinity?
By Andy Doan
May 29, 2008 - 9:32:12 PM

DC Comics
Email this article
 Printer friendly page

Add to Del.icio.us     Add To Reddit
Add To Digg     Add To Stumbleupon
Add To Technorati Favorites     Add To Ask


537158570_475434e4d7.jpg
DC is getting ready to launch it's third weekly title in three years. The warm glow of 52 has long since flickered out while the smell of Countdown still lingers. While I'm not willing to be dragged into another year long train wreck I would hate to miss something really cool. Before I'm willing to add this title to my pull list I'll have to review all the things it has going for and against it.

I'm a sucker for Batman and Superman. As of right now I've been picking up almost everything with these two on the cover. They are my anchor to the DCU (besides Green Lantern). Two vastly different yet equally powerful characters who have been admired by millions of people for years. There is still so much that can be done with these two after all these years and I want to have a front row seat.

I've been on the fence about Wonder Woman for a while. This might be a good introduction. She's played a small role in lots of different titles (other then her own book) lately but never more then a taste. Trinity will allow a tough manly man (like me) a chance to read a title featuring a strong female lead without letting everyone know about it.

I liked the weekly format of 52 and Countdown. In fact the weekly format was the only thing that kept me interested. It seemed that after every issue I would say to myself "Next week it'll be better". It was this alone that keep me hanging on until the bitter end. Perhaps there is a need within some fans for constant iteration? Kind of like a soap opera in it's way. Not engrossing but comforting in it's regularity.

Part of the charm of 52 and Countdown was being able to spend time with the C and D listed characters. These are folks who are rough around the edges and that make mistakes on a regular basis. Trinity offers three perfect heroes. They always win (they have to).

cover1.jpg
52 was almost a revolutionary book. It was week after week of plot twists and turns featuring a group of second tier yet interesting characters. It was entertaining while at it's worst and at it's greatest it was one of the best book out at the time. The Black Adam arch alone was worth the price of admission. If they can tap into a small portion of the vibe from this series they might be able to make it work.

52 was a long time ago now and Countdown was 52 issues of pointlessness. Countdown failed in all of the ways that 52 succeeded. DC has a habit of beating things into the ground (they couldn't leave Kingdom Come alone) I know that they would have no problem trowing another steaming load onto the pile.

Kurt Busiek is cool. I still have strong love for him from the original run on Astro City. He has certainly become more prolific then profound lately. This new title might be a chance for him to shake a little of the dust off and introduce the world of comics to something truly unique. No one can deny the fact that he has the the ability within him.

The only problem with Busiek is that he might be a little burnt out. The last little bit of his Superman run seemed to drag quite a bit. The old and established characters might not be the best way for him to tell a really interesting story.

The four horse men mini series featured Batman, Superman and Wonder Women standing around trading sarcastic in-jokes with each other. Not as bad as some of the recent work by Judd Winick but not good either. I would want to explore the things about each character that we're unfamiliar with rather then know link between them.

There was potential in the 4 Horse Men series they may not have been fully released. They are after all three very different characters with profoundly different motivations. Well planned and well written there could be a number of very interesting places this book could take us. For example... Could Wonder Woman have feelings for Bruce? Does Bruce have a contingency plan for Wonder Woman like he does for Superman. Does one of them feel superior to the others?

What are we really risking here? This story takes place outside of current continuity. That means that the characters have to come out the same way they go in. How much can these characters possibly change by the end of the run?

The bottom line?

b_Bagleyart_1.jpg
I'm going to end up getting it.

For one thing I'm that type of person. I'm willing to be lead by large companies into spending money on things that I don't really need. Besides there's just something cool about getting an update on a story line every week rather than every month. It worked for 52 and Countdown and it's really working for Amazing Spider-man. It'll likely work for Trinity.

This time I'm hoping I have the strength to walk away if the series is headed down the drain. I know that they likely have the script for the entire run at least in a first draft state and they're not likely to change mid stream even if the public is a little slow on the uptake. If the series is boring after the first couple issue I know it's going to stay that way. DC seems to take a little longer then most to actually get into a series so I'm going to give them 6 issues. That accounts for half of Busiek's run, if he can't show me the light in six weeks it's unlikely that his lower paid lesser known associates will do much better.

***UPDATE***
Read "Everything Trinity" for a full run down on the series



Related Articles:
Trinity # 9
Trinity # 5
Trinity # 4
Trinity # 1
Marvel Presents Mark Millar's Trinity
Everything Trinity
Am I Buying Trinity?
DC Comics' "Trinity" Starts Thick
TOKYOPOP Fiction: Trinity Blood: Reborn on the Mars, Vol. 1
Broken Saints - Chapter 10 - "Trinity"



Comment Script Join the discussion:

Add a Comment

Comments

I don't know. I'm not interested thus far. There is already a Superman /Batman series and I'm not reading that. It feels like a love in series for the World's Finest and I'm tired of the self congratulatory type of stories at DC .

I'm afraid that Trinity will do the same thing. Plus, it goes against what I've been arguing for a while that DC neglects its second tier characters in favour of it's so-called Trinity. Why Didn't DC do a trinity series with say it's second trinity - Green Arrow, Green Lantern and Black Canary, instead? That type of series would be more involved and would be a great sequel to the classic Green Arrow / Green Lantern series from the 1960s and 1970s. That previous story actually explored some new grounds.

I'm afraid Trinity will be nothing more than what we've seen before, especially if it's outside continuity. I'm tired of having DC telling that I should pay a lot attention to Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman, instead of trying to propel its other characters.

So I guess I won't be reading this one. And if it turns out that it's good and a must read - I seriously doubt it - Busiek works better on short ended stories - His Aquaman series last year was painful and probably contributed to its cancelling - well if it turns out any good, there will always be the trade paperback.
#1 - Hervé St-Louis - 05/30/2008 - 08:51
I know!
I know it's going to suck but I still have to give DC the benefit of the doubt! I know they are going to try and but out a high quality product. I know they don't want to rip off one of their loyal fans.

I do agree with your basic point. Nothing about this book has me really jumping out of my seat. There was never a "Together at last!" moment when I was reading the promotional material for the series. Give me 52 more issues of Animal man, Booster Gold and Black Adam and I'll take notice.
#2 - Andy Doan - 05/30/2008 - 23:39

© Copyright 2002-2008, Coolstreak Cartoons Inc. - All rights Reserved. All other texts, images, characters and trademarks are copyright their respective owners. Use of material in this document(including reproduction, modification, distribution, electronic transmission or republication) without prior written permission is strictly prohibited.

Top of Page

Search

Boom Studio, IDW Publishing, Radical Comics – The New Triumvirate
As they grow bigger and more important, are these publishers losing track of the little guy?
Aspen Comics After Mike Turner
Mike won’t be here to see everything we had planned for Aspen Comics, but his company plans on staying live for a long time.”
San Diego Comic-Con The Flea Market
The flea market at the San Diego Comic-Con (officially not called a flea market but an exhibitors’ area) is where most of the action on the ground floor of the convention takes place
CryptoZooey Shows That Comic Books For Kids Are Alive In San Diego Comic-Con
CryptoZooey is about Zooey, a young girl who learns that her parents are world renowned cryptozoologists
Omega The Unknown, A Look At A Remarkable Marvel Series
As we look forward to the trade, a look back at one of the best comics of 2008.
Watchmen Objections - Storytelling and the Storyboard
I seriously doubt that Snyder will successfully pull this off intellectually, understanding what The Watchmen did as comic book and what it could do as a movie
Superheroes Fashion And Fantasy
A visit to The Metropolitan Museum of Art yields some very cool superhero surprises.
Why The Comic Book Bin Does Not Gossip
While all of the comic book industry punditry is busy chasing and covering the latest crisis, the folks at The Comic Book Bin look elsewhere. Why is that?
Spider-Man Stole My Cookie
Did you know that the 2002 Spider-Man flick began a infestation of our summer movie season? If you don't know, you better ask somebody - somebody like Mr. Charlie.
Three Shadows
First Second has lived up to its highest standards in bringing this exquisite work of art and poetry to North American audiences.
Everything Trinity
All the stuff you need to know about DC's weekly series set to launch Wednesday June 4th.
Am I Buying Trinity?
DC is ready with it's latest weekly series. Is it worth the extra weight on your pull list?
Green Lantern is DC Comics’ Iron Man
Can Green Lantern become DC Comics' next film success like Iron Man or is the publisher too intent on restricting his popularity?
Superman's Best Known Secret
The idea of a truly secret identity seems a little harder to swallow then a flying man from outer space.
Classics Illustrated #1: Great Expectations
When kid-friendly publisher Papercutz resurrected the Classics Illustrated brand this year, the same old question came to mind. What positive literary merit can be found in comic-book adaptations of great literature?